Hunting and persecution by humans
Humans have always used birds as a resource, while at the same time decimating species they considered undesirable. In both cases, birds are removed from a population or harmed by the side effects of such actions. Direct persecution has diminished in Switzerland thanks to better protection. Today, hunting birds is regarded as a sport and leisure activity.
To evaluate the impact of hunting and of hunting regulation, it is necessary to carefully examine whether hunting has negative effects on the distribution, population trend, demographic indicators and social structure of the species concerned. Such an examination must take into account that core areas with large, interconnected populations and a high reproductive rate are extremely important to maintain the overall population structure. Hunting regulations therefore need to consider the influence of changing environmental conditions.
Side effects of hunting: lead poisoning and disturbance
Lead ammunition is a threat to birds. Lead poisoning leads to impairment and death, affecting mainly birds of prey that feed on carrion as well as waterbirds. In the European Union, an estimated 400 000 to 1 500 000 birds die from lead poisoning every year. Scavengers (e.g. Bearded Vulture and Golden Eagle) ingest the lead when they feed on animals that have been shot but not retrieved. Populations of species that are long-lived and have a low reproductive rate are particularly sensitive to the loss of individuals. Waterbirds take up lead shot when foraging, mistaking it for food or grit. In Switzerland, the use of lead shot to hunt waterbirds has been prohibited since 2012.
In many cases, hunting causes massive disturbance, as it generally takes place in areas where visitors are scarce, and because hunters are often accompanied by dogs. Disturbance has a particularly large impact on waterbirds, as it drives them from their resting and foraging grounds, sometimes for the long term. This can cause waterbirds to alter their temporal and spatial activity pattern or abandon the site.
Decimation of undesirable species
In the past, humans persecuted birds they considered pests either by hunting them or destroying their nests. Populations of Great Crested Grebe, Grey Heron, Golden Eagle, Northern Goshawk, Carrion Crow, Common Raven and others were decimated. Bearded Vulture and Osprey were eradicated throughout the country, the Eurasian Magpie in Ticino. Red Kite and Eurasian Eagle-owl were on the brink of extinction in Switzerland. Since the first federal hunting act in 1875, interventions at the nest have been restricted, close seasons extended, and the list of game birds continually reduced. Many species whose populations had been decimated recovered as a result. The colonisation and spread of Great Cormorant and Rook are a consequence of improved international protection. Effective protection is a fundamental requirement for the successful reintroduction of extinct species, like in the case of the Bearded Vulture.
Hunting of birds along their migration routes
In many countries, migratory birds are hunted legally or illegally. The number of legally hunted migrants is hard to determine, as few hunting statistics exist. In the Mediterranean region, an estimated 11 to 35 million birds are killed illegally every year. While the impact of hunting abroad on Swiss breeding bird populations is difficult to gauge, it has probably contributed to the decline of native birds like European Turtle-dove or Ortolan Bunting. The spring hunt in particular has a direct impact on breeding birds.
Hunting of Black Grouse, Rock Ptarmigan and Eurasian Woodcock in Switzerland
Black Grouse populations in Switzerland show varying regional trends, and the species is considered Near Threatened. The size of local populations depends mainly on the weather during the breeding season and the intensity of disturbance from human recreation. In many suitable habitats, disturbance from leisure activities prevents populations from reaching capacity. From 1997 to 2016, about 550 Black Grouse males were shot every year in Switzerland. The females are protected. According to data from the «Ufficio caccia e pesca Canton Ticino», hunting raises Black Grouse mortality and produces a biased sex ratio.
The Rock Ptarmigan is another species that is classified as Near Threatened, but whether hunting contributes to its negative population trend has not been studied. On average, about 580 individuals were shot annually in the past 20 years. Locally, excessive bag limits may contribute to the decline.
From 1997 to 2016, about 2000 Eurasian Woodcocks were killed in Switzerland every year, most of them originating from northern and eastern European populations. Hunting in France has been shown to increase mortality in northeastern European populations. Hunting in Switzerland presumably has a similar effect. Since 1993–1996, the Eurasian Woodcock has almost completely disappeared as a breeding bird below 900 m in Switzerland. Besides habitat degradation, predation and disturbance, additional mortality from hunting is a possible cause of the negative trend. Data from birds tagged with transmitters show that while many native Woodcocks leave with the first snowfall, others remain in Switzerland, sometimes as late as mid-December and thus well beyond the close season.
In the past, human persecution had a considerable impact on the populations of many of our native breeding birds. As legal protection improved, the affected species were able to recover. But still today, there are attempts to decimate the populations of species that are considered undesirable. This is unacceptable from an ecological point of view.
Given the huge number of birds affected, legal and illegal persecution abroad presumably has an effect on our native breeding populations. In Switzerland today, hunting only affects populations at the regional level and/or in the case of certain species. Hunting of species with stable or increasing populations, regulated according to the specific circumstances, can be accepted from an ecological point of view if the threat at the European and national level is taken into account and hunting has no measurable negative effects on the distribution, population size and social structure of the species concerned. Regular monitoring of populations is a prerequisite.
Bregnballe, T., J. Madsen & P. A. F. Rasmussen (2004): Effects of temporal and spatial hunting control in waterbird reserves. Biol. Conserv. 119: 93–104.
Brochet, A.-L., W. van den Bossche, S. Jbour, P. K. Ndang’abg’a, V. R. Jones, Abdou, W. A. L. I., A. R. Al-Hmoud, N. G. Asswad, J. C. Atienza, I. Atrash, N. Barbara, K. Bensusan, T. Bino, C. Celada, S. I. Cherkaoui, J. Costa, B. Deceuninck, K. S. Etayeb, C. Feltrup-Azafzaf, J. Figelj, M. Gustin, P. Kmecl, V. Kocevski, M. Kerbeti, D. Kotrošan, J. Mula Laguna, M. Lattuada, D. Leitão, P. Lopes, N. López-Jiménez, V. Lucić, T. Micol, A. Moali, Y. Perlman, N. Piludu, D. Portolou, K. Putilin, G. Quaintenne, G. Ramadan-Jaradi, M. Ružić, A. Sandor, N. Sarajli, D. Savelić, R. D. Sheldon, T. Shialis, N. Tsiopelas, F. Vargas, C. Thompson, A. Brunner, R. Grimmett & S. H. M. Butchart (2016): Preliminary assessment of the scope and scale of illegal killing and taking of birds in the Mediterranean. Bird Conserv. Int. 26: 1–28.
Brüngger, M. & F. Estoppey (2008): Exigences écologiques de la Bécasse des bois Scolopax rusticola dans les Préalpes de Suisse occidentale. Nos Oiseaux 55: 3–22.
del Hoyo, J., A. Elliott, J. Sargatal, D. A. Christie & E. de Juana (2017): Handbook of the birds of the world Alive. Lynx Edicions, Barcelona. https://www.hbw.com (22.11.2017).
European Chemicals Agency (2017): Annex XV restriction report - lead in shot. Proposal for a restriction. European Chemicals Agency, Helsinki. https://echa.europa.eu/documents/10162/13641/restrictions_lead_shot_axv_report_en.pdf/6ef877d5-94b7-a8f8-1c49-8c07c894fff7 (Stand: 26.4.2018).
Evans, D. M. & K. R. Day (2002): Hunting disturbance on a large shallow lake: the effectiveness of waterfowl refuges. Ibis 144: 2–8.
Ferrand, Y., P. Aubry, P. Landry & P. Priol (2013): Responses of Eurasian woodcock Scolopax rusticola to simulated hunting disturbance. Wildl. Biol. 19: 19–29.
Fisher, I., J. Ashpole, D. Scallan, C. Carboneras & T. Proud (2018): International single species action plan for the conservation of the European Turtle-dove Streptopelia turtur (2018 to 2028). European Commission Technical Report. Office for Official Publications of the European Commission, Luxembourg.
Franson, J. C. & D. J. Pain (2011): Lead in birds. S. 563–594 in: W. N. Beyer & J. P. Meador (Hrsg.): Environmental contaminants in biota. Interpreting tissue concentrations. 2nd ed. CRC Press, Boca Raton.
Furrer, R., M. Schaub, A. Bossert, R. Isler, H. Jenny, T. Jonas, C. Marti & L. Jenni (2016): Variable decline of Alpine Rock Ptarmigan (Lagopus muta helvetica) in Switzerland between regions and sites. J. Ornithol. 157: 787–796.
Glutz von Blotzheim, U. N. & K. M. Bauer (1966–1997): Handbuch der Vögel Mitteleuropas. Bd. 1–3 von K. M. Bauer & U. N. Glutz von Blotzheim bearbeitet, Bd. 4–7 von U. N. Glutz von Blotzheim, K. M. Bauer & E. Bezzel sowie Bd. 8–14 von U. N. Glutz von Blotzheim & K. M. Bauer. Mehrere Bände seither in der 2., durchges. Aufl. Akademische Verlagsgesellschaft, Wiesbaden (bis 1982) bzw. Aula, Wiesbaden.
Jenni, L., M. M. Madry, T. Kraemer, J. Kupper, H. Naegeli, H. Jenny & D. Jenny (2015): The frequency distribution of lead concentration in feathers, blood, bone, kidney and liver of golden eagles Aquila chrysaetos: insights into the modes of uptake. J. Ornithol. 156: 1095–1103.
Jiguet, F., R. Arlettaz, H.-G. Bauer, V. Belik, J. L. Copete, L. Couzi, M. A. Czajkowski, S. Dale, V. Dombrovski, J. Elts, Y. Ferrand, R. Hargues, G. M. Kirwan, S. Minkevicius, M. Piha, G. Selstam, M. Skierczyński, J.-P. Siblet & A. Sokolov (2016): An update of the European breeding population sizes and trends of the Ortolan Bunting (Emberiza hortulana). Ornis Fenn. 93: 186–196.
Knaus, P., R. Graf, J. Guélat, V. Keller, H. Schmid & N. Zbinden (2011): Historischer Brutvogelatlas. Die Verbreitung der Schweizer Brutvögel seit 1950/Atlas historique des oiseaux nicheurs. La répartition des oiseaux nicheurs de Suisse depuis 1950. Schweizerische Vogelwarte/Station ornithologique suisse, Sempach.
Madry, M. M., T. Kraemer, J. Kupper, H. Naegeli, H. Jenny, L. Jenni & D. Jenny (2015): Excessive lead burden among golden eagles in the Swiss Alps. Environ. Res. Lett. 10: 034003, doi: 10.1088/1748-9326/10/3/034003.
Madsen, H., N. Bunnefeld, S. Nagy, C. Griffin, P. Du Defos Rau, J.-Y. Moundain-Monval, R. Hearn, A. Czajkowski, A. Grauer, F. R. Merkel, J. H. Williams, M. Alhainen, M. Guillemain, A. Middleton, T. K. Christensen & O. Noe (2015): Guidelines on sustainable harvest of migratory waterbirds. AEWA Conservation No. 5, AEWA Technical Series No. 62. Wetlands International, Bonn.
Martínez-Abraín, A., C. Viedma, J. A. Gómez, M. A. Bartolomé, J. Jiménez, M. Genovart & S. Tenan (2013): Assessing the effectiveness of a hunting moratorium on target and non-target species. Biol. Conserv. 165: 171–178.
Mollet, P. (2017a): Auf der Fährte der Waldschnepfe. Avinews 2017/3: 6–7.
Mollet, P. (2017b): Sulle tracce della Beccaccia. Avinews 2017/3: 6–7.
Mollet, P. (2017c): Sur les traces de la bécasse des bois. Avinews 2017/3: 6–7.
Pain, D. J., I. J. Fisher & V. G. Thomas (2009): A global update of lead poisoning in terrestrial birds from ammunition sources. S. 99–118 in: R. T. Watson, M. Fuller, M. Pokras & W. G. Hunt (Hrsg.): Ingestion of lead from spent ammunition: Implications for wildlife and humans. The Peregrine Fund, Boise.
Patthey, P., S. Wirthner, N. Signorell & R. Arlettaz (2008): Impact of outdoor winter sports on the abundance of a key indicator species of alpine ecosystems. J. Appl. Ecol. 45: 1704–1711.
Péron, G., Y. Ferrand, F. Gossmann, C. Bastat, M. Guenezan & O. Gimenez (2011): Nonparametric spatial regression of survival probability: visualization of population sinks in Eurasian Woodcock. Ecology 92: 1672–1679.
Zbinden, N. & M. Salvioni (2003): Verbreitung, Siedlungsdichte und Fortpflanzungserfolg des Birkhuhns Tetrao tetrix im Tessin 1981-2002. Ornithol. Beob. 100: 211–226.
Zbinden, N., M. Salvioni, F. Korner-Nievergelt & V. Keller (2018): Evidence for an additive effect of hunting mortality in an alpine black grouse Lyrurus tetrix population. Wildl. Biol. 2018, doi: 10.2981/wlb.00418.